Eric Evenstad

The Tiny Decisions That Turn Red Trades Green

The Tiny Decisions That Turn Red Trades Green

Eric Evenstad • November 12, 2023

Read Time: 3 Minutes

This week we saw three days of choppy price action on $SPY followed by heavy selling on Thursday, and then even heavier buying on Friday. 


It was a frustrating trading week for me because my trade plans were rock solid all week but I wasn't able to capitalize. Here are the results of my first four trades so that you can see what I'm talking about:


Trade #1: Stopped out for a loss after $SPY came within one cent of my first profit target.


Trade #2: Stopped out for a loss after $SPY came within one cent of my first profit target.


Trade #3: Stopped out for a loss after $SPY came within one cent of my first profit target.


Trade #4: Stopped out for a loss after $SPY wicked down, hit my stop loss on the dot, and then went on to hit all three of my profit targets. 


You can't make this stuff up. The difference between losing all four trades and winning all four trades came down to a total of FOUR cents. 


It was infuriating, to say the least, and unfortunately, it led to some hesitating and fearful trading the rest of the week. 


Luckily, there are some lessons that I can take from this week to become a better trader. Here's my biggest takeaway:

The Line Between Success and Failure Is Razor Thin

Each of my first four trades should have been a winner but tiny execution errors led to all four being losers. Entering a trade a hair early, chasing a trade and getting in a couple of cents late, setting a stop loss that it is a little too wide or a little too tight.


These little decisions might seem insignificant in the moment, but many times they are the difference between a winning trade and a losing trade.


It isn't enough to be "mostly" patient or "mostly" disciplined. You have to be all in. If you want these types of trades to go green you must decide to:

  • Wait patiently for the trade to come all the way to you. FOMO-ing in early forces you to set wider stop losses and wider profit targets, which increases your risk and decreases your odds of success.
  • Resist the urge to chase trades and remember that there will always be more opportunities to come. Sometimes, waiting for your target entry means that you'll narrowly miss entering a winning trade. It's painful to watch a trade take off without you, but it's even more painful to chase the trade, have price reverse on you, and then take an unnecessarily big loss. 
  • Fight your feelings of fear so that you can set proper stop losses at proper invalidation points. My fourth trade is a perfect example of fearful trading. After taking losses on my first three trades, I set an unnecessarily tight stop loss on my fourth trade. I did this to reduce the amount of money I could lose on the trade - as if I was planning on losing the trade before I even entered it. Not surprisingly, this resulted in me getting stopped out of a would-be winning trade before the trade was actually invalidated.
  • Fight your feelings of greed so that you can set proper profit targets. Early on, I learned that you should move your profit targets ahead of key support/resistance levels on the chart and you should also move them ahead of round numbers. But this week was a good reminder that it's equally important to lock in profits when you see momentum slowing. Saying "That's close enough" and locking in profits a little early is always better than letting a green trade turn red.

These are the type of tiny decisions that separate breakeven traders from the consistently profitable ones. 


The difference between losing $150 on my first four trades and profiting $300+ on my first four trades came down to four cents; and that four cents came down to tiny decision-making errors.


It's deeply irritating to lose those trades by such a thin margin but it's also satisfying to see how far I've come. It wasn't long ago that the difference between losing and winning was $0.25 per trade, then $0.10, then $0.05. 


It takes a lot of trial and error but if you keep trying to master these tiny decisions, the gap between success and failure will continue to shrink, and eventually, the narrow losses will turn into big wins. 


Have a great week,

​Eric

Join the Day Trading Inner Circle

Follow along as I strive to become a profitable day trader. Every Sunday, I send out an email with my weekly trading stats plus the most important learning resources that I discovered that week. Drop your email in the box below to join the inner circle.

Home Newsletter Signup

Previous Issues of Side Hustle Steroids

4 Key Insights From a Year of Weekly Writing
By Eric Evenstad December 31, 2023
4 Key Insights From a Year of Weekly Writing
10 Day Trading Insights I wish I knew sooner
By Eric Evenstad December 24, 2023
10 Day Trading Insights I wish I knew sooner
a laptop on a table with the words analyze your trades like a pro using tradezilla
By Eric Evenstad December 17, 2023
Last week, I shared my 10 must-have tools for day traders, and today I want to dive a bit deeper into one of those tools in particular. TradeZella is the all-in-one trading journal and analytics software that I use to analyze my trade data and fine-tune my setups and strategies. It's a tool I highly recommend, and today, I'll explain why I'm such a big fan while also showing you how I've integrated it into my daily trading routine.
a laptop on a table with the words my complete day trading toolkit
By Eric Evenstad December 10, 2023
Step up your trading game by exploring my 10 must-have tools for day traders. I cover everything from trading platforms and software to educational resources and useful gear. Dive in and discover the key tools that can lead to trading success.
An inside look at my day trading screen setup
By Eric Evenstad December 3, 2023
An inside look at my day trading screen setup
Overcoming Stress as a Day Trader
By Eric Evenstad November 26, 2023
Overcoming Stress as a Day Trader
Reach profitability faster by studying the trades you should have taken
By Eric Evenstad November 19, 2023
Reach profitability faster by studying the trades you should have taken
My 30-Minute Chart Studying Routine
By Eric Evenstad November 5, 2023
Improve your win rate and identify new trade setups with this 30-minute chart studying routine.
How to stay motivated and defeat burnout as a new trader
By Eric Evenstad October 29, 2023
How to stay motivated and defeat burnout as a new trader
How to Predict the Size of a Move Using the Trendline Tool
By Eric Evenstad October 22, 2023
How to Predict the Size of a Move Using the Trendline Tool
More Posts
Share by: